Sunday, May 18, 2025

SCOTUS PUNTS ALIEN ENEMIES CASE

By Bob Walsh

 

a cartoon of donald trump sitting in front of a computer
"God damn it, and to think that I appointed those fucking clowns."
 
 
The Supreme Court punted, or at least semi-punted, the use of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to deport Venezuelan gang members.  SCOTUS did not say that the Trump administration could not use the law.  They did say that they had to give the criminals some level of meaningful opportunity to demonstrate that they were not a member of the class of people in question, and that 24 hours was not enough time. 

SCOTUS moved the case back to the lower court for further action at that level, acknowledging that they were not best suited to oversee the nuts and bolts of a case centered half a continent away from DC. 

No comments: