Wednesday, December 04, 2024

NY MAYOR DEFENDS DANIEL PENNY ..... PRAISES PENNY FOR TAKING AN ACTION-BASED APPROACH IN RESPONSE TO NEELY'S THREATS TO SUBWAY PASSENFERS

New York City Mayor Eric Adams makes shock intervention in Daniel Penny case

 

By Alyssa Guzman 


Daily Mail

Dec 4, 2024

 

New York City Mayor Eric Adams launched a defense of his new $53million program that would give pre-paid food cards to migrants, saying it will save food delivery companies money

New York City Mayor Eric Adams, 64, joined the Rob Astorino Show on Saturday, where the pair briefly discussed the Daniel Penny trial, which has gripped the city since the former Marine was accused of killing homeless man Jordan Neely on the an F train in Manhattan in May 2023
 

New York City Mayor Eric Adams defended the actions of Daniel Penny, whose trial over the use of a fatal chokehold on homeless man Jordan Neely is now in the hands of a jury.

Adams, 64, joined the Rob Astorino Show on Saturday, where the pair briefly discussed the trial, which has gripped the city since the former Marine was accused of killing Neely on the an F train in Manhattan in May 2023. 

'Those passengers were afraid. I've been on the subway system. I know what it is as a police officer to wrestle or fight with someone,' he told the host. 

'It is imperative that we look at the totality of this problem.'

Adams praised Penny, 26, for taking an action-based approach in response to Neely's threats to passengers that day.

'We're on the subway where we're hearing someone talking about hurting people, killing people,' the mayor said. 

'You have someone on that subway who was responding, doing what we should have done as a city in a state of having a mental health facility.'

Adams added that photographs that circulated showing Penny as a subway performer impersonating Michael Jackson skewed the public's perception.

'It seemed like it was a young, innocent child who was brutally murdered, and it gave that impression,' the mayor said. 

'When you look at the photo that was being used, it wanted to set up in the minds of people that we were dealing with a young, innocent child, just a Michael Jackson imitator that was just brutally assaulted.' 

Neely, 30, had a long rap sheet and had a history of mental illness. When the Michael Jackson impersonator stepped on the F train that day, he began making threats at passengers and said he wasn't afraid to go back to jail. 

Penny grabbed him in a chokehold and wrestled him to the ground, where he subdued him for several minutes on the train. 

Video footage shows Neely struggling to get out of the hold before eventually going limp, despite passengers telling the former soldier to let go. 

Penny now faces manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide charges as prosecutors accuse him of using lethal force unjustifiably. 

He has pleaded not guilty to the charges. Penny faces up to 19 years behind bars if convicted.

His attorneys argue that Penny was only trying to protect others in the subway car. 

For Adams, who was recently federally indicted, the case was about more than if Penny should spend time behind bars, but about the failing system in New York City, which he has run since January 2022. 

'You look at the complete failure of our mental health system, a complete failure,' he said on the show. 'From the days of closing psychiatric wards and having those who needed help just turned over into the street without giving any safety net to accept them.

'What do we do? A system where you brought people into hospitals, gave them medicine for one day, and sent them back.' 

 

Penny grabbed Nelly in a chokehold (pictured) and wrestled him to the ground, where he subdued him for several minutes on the train after Neely threatened passengers

Penny grabbed Nelly in a chokehold (pictured) and wrestled him to the ground, where he subdued him for several minutes on the train after Neely threatened passengers

Video footage shows Neely struggling to get out of the hold before eventually going limp, despite passengers telling the former soldier to let go

Video footage shows Neely struggling to get out of the hold before eventually going limp, despite passengers telling the former soldier to let go

Neely, 30, had a long rap sheet and had a history of mental illness. Adams called the mental health system in the Big Apple a 'revolving door' and one that Neely - like many others - kept rotating through. He slammed the media for using this picture and others like it, that painted Neely as harmless

Neely, 30, had a long rap sheet and had a history of mental illness. Adams called the mental health system in the Big Apple a 'revolving door' and one that Neely - like many others - kept rotating through. He slammed the media for using this picture and others like it, that painted Neely as harmless 

 

He called the mental health system in the Big Apple a 'revolving door' and one that Neely - like many others - kept rotating through. 

'We have to recognize we have a mental health crisis, and we're not doing enough to solve it,' the mayor said. 

Penny's case is currently in deliberations as a jury of seven women and five men decide his fate.  

Adams - who became the first NYC mayor to ever be indicted in office - also criticized the migrant problem in the city, which saw him begging for state funds to help support the mass influx. 

At the beginning of the year, Adams begged Governor Kathy Hochul for $4.6billion to cover the cost of the migrants flooding into the sanctuary city. 

Busloads of migrants from Florida and Texas were shipped to NYC, which only hurt the City That Never Sleep's system even more. 

The heavy influx eventually led Adams to take a trip to Latin America - where many migrants are coming from - to warn them they won't be getting a 'five-star hotel' experience in the city in hopes of convincing others to make alternative plans. 

On Saturday, Adams revealed it cost the city $6.4billion to cover the migrant crisis. 

He recently shocked journalists and residents when he said he would 'love' to work with President-Elect Donald Trump's border czar nominee Tom Homan to deport criminal migrants. 

The Democrat politician, who has signaled he will be running for a second term in 2025, said he is not afraid to be 'canceled' by being 'honest about the truth' when it comes to immigration.

'Those who are here committing crimes - robberies, shooting at police officers, raping innocent people - have been a harm to our country,' former NYPD captain Adams, 64, told a news conference on Tuesday.

'Those are the people I am talking about and I would love to sit down with the border czar and hear his thoughts on how we're going to address those who are harming our citizens.'

IT IS LIKELY THAT THE HAMAS TERRORISTS GUARDING THE HOSTAGES KILLED THEM SHORTLY AFTER AN ISRAELI AIRSTRIKE

6 hostages whose bodies were returned in August were murdered in captivity

Hostages and Missing Families Forum reports IDF informed them that Alexander Dancyg, Yoram Metzger, Chaim Perry, Yagev Buchshtab, Nadav Popplewell, and Avraham Munder were executed by gunfire inside a Gaza tunnel after an Israeli airstrike targeted underground infrastructure in the area.

 

By Lilach Shoval and Noam Dvir  

 

Israel Hayom

Dec 4, 2024

 

Israel recovered the bodies of 6 hostages from the Khan Yunis area in Gaza, who were murdered in Hamas captivity

 

The families of six hostages whose bodies were returned to Israel in August 2024 were informed by the IDF this week that their loved ones were killed in Hamas captivity. According to military findings, the hostages – Alexander Dancyg, Yoram Metzger, Chaim Perry, Yagev Buchshtab, Nadav Popplewell, and Avraham Munder – were executed by gunfire inside a Gaza tunnel after an Israeli airstrike targeted underground infrastructure in the area. The military believes the hostages were likely killed shortly after the attack.

According to a military investigation, it is likely that the Hamas terrorists guarding the hostages killed them shortly after the Israeli airstrike. The military does not rule out the possibility that other Hamas operatives may have executed the hostages, although this remains unlikely.

The six Hamas terrorists who had been guarding the hostages were found dead in the tunnel, likely from asphyxiation caused by toxic gas released during the airstrike. At the time, there was no reason to suspect hostages were in the area, and the IDF did not consider the possibility when planning the strike.

The results of the investigation were presented to the families, who were told that even if their loved ones had not been shot, they would have likely died from inhaling toxic fumes from the attack.

 

 

Israelis rallying for the release of the hostages held by the Hamas terrorist organization in the Gaza Strip 

 

The hostages had been held in an underground facility until December 2023. After an Israeli ground operation, they were moved to a tunnel in the Hamed neighborhood, about 2.5 miles away, where their last known image was taken.

On Feb. 14, 2024, the IDF conducted a targeted strike in the area without knowing that hostages were nearby. Five months later, intelligence indicated that the hostages had likely perished. In August 2024, their bodies were retrieved from the tunnel.

IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi acknowledged the failure and emphasized that the mission to bring the hostages home continues. "We are doing everything we can to bring them back. Every mistake we make is a result of a lack of information, and we must learn from them."

Noam Perry, daughter of Chaim Perry, said, "The public must understand that military operations endanger hostages. We need to secure a deal now – there is no other way."

BUT WHAT DID TRUMP MEAN BY 'THERE WILL BE HELL TO PAY IN THE MIDDLE EAST'?

Trump voices the moral clarity on hostages the world needed

The president-elect’s threat—“There will be all Hell to pay in the Middle East”—if Hamas didn’t release its captives before his inauguration sent a message to Iran. 

 

By Jonathan S. Tobin

 

JNS

Dec 4, 2024

 

GOP presidential candidate and former President Donald Trump takes photos with the family of Edan Alexander at the Ohel in Queens, N.Y., the resting place of Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson (the Lubavitcher Rebbe), one year after the Hamas-led terrorist attacks and kidnappings in southern Israel, Oct. 7, 2024. Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images. 

GOP presidential candidate and former President Donald Trump takes photos with the family of Edan Alexander at the Ohel in Queens, N.Y., the resting place of Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson (the Lubavitcher Rebbe), one year after the Hamas-led terrorist attacks and kidnappings in southern Israel, Oct. 7, 2024.

 

We don’t know yet what impact President-elect Donald Trump’s bombshell statement about the fate of the Israeli hostages still held by Hamas will be. But in one post on his Truth Social site, he neatly summarized what has been lacking in terms of American leadership when it comes to the fight against Iranian-funded Islamist terrorism for the past four years.

Trump’s post—with its characteristic bombastic tone and use of capital letters for emphasis—was very different from the public statements of the Biden administration foreign-policy team in recent months on the same topic or that of any other world leader. The United States has condemned Hamas, but in the last year has been primarily focused on pressuring Israel to give up its campaign to eliminate the terrorists and agree to a ceasefire with only a partial release of the hostages. That would effectively hand the perpetrators an undeserved victory for the massacre of 1,200 men, women and children in Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.

Instead, Trump put the onus for achieving the release of the hostages—something all decent people should support—on the Palestinians. They were responsible for that rampage of mass murder, torture, rape and kidnapping. But by specifying that the “All HELL TO PAY” would be felt throughout the Middle East, he was also sending a powerful message to Hamas’s foreign backers. Iran, as well as nominal U.S. allies like Qatar and Turkey, who have provided the terrorists with aid and diplomatic cover are also now on notice to secure the hostages’ freedom lest they, too, face Trump’s wrath once he returns to the White House on Jan. 20.

It’s true that the Biden administration has been working on trying to broker a deal that would lead to the release of at least some of the 101 hostages (approximately 60 are believed to be alive) that are still unaccounted for. But there has been no such unambiguous message from Washington about what it expects from the Hamas terrorist organization or its allies in the Muslim and Arab worlds. Instead, and in keeping with its consistent efforts to undermine and topple the government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu since Israelis elected it in November 2022, Biden has wanted Netanyahu to make concessions that wouldn’t return all the hostages at once and that would hand over Gaza to the weak and corrupt Palestinian Authority, which has, despite its rivalry with Hamas, never condemned the atrocities that took place on Oct. 7. That is a formula to ensure that Hamas would soon return to power there, leaving Israel in as much danger as it was when the Palestinians started this war.

Wanting Israel to ‘finish’ and win

Trump has made no secret of his desire for a clean slate in the Middle East when he takes office, with Israel having completed its wars against both Hamas in the south and Hezbollah to the north. While that puts Netanyahu on notice that the next administration is hoping not to be distracted from its domestic priorities by conflict in the Middle East, Trump was equally clear that he had no compunctions about the severity of Israeli military actions in Gaza or Lebanon. He just wants the Israelis to “finish” and achieve “victory” over Hamas—an idea that the Biden team has consistently opposed. Once that victory is achieved, Trump is obviously hoping to pick up where he left off when he left office four years ago by building on the 2020 Abraham Accords, which normalized relations between Israel and four Arab and Muslim-majority nations.

Many of Trump’s critics were predictably appalled by his hostage post because of its tone and what they consider to be his bias in favor of Israel and against the Palestinians. Despite starting the war with barbaric atrocities and sticking to their goal of wiping Israel off the map and committing genocide against the Jews, Hamas and its supporters—a category that includes what may well be a majority of Palestinians as well as their cheerleaders in the international media and on American college campuses—expect themselves to be depicted as the sole victims in the conflict.

Biden’s willingness to kowtow to that mindset has undermined his administration’s efforts to end the war.

He did so in part out of an instinctual desire to curry favor with the international community, which is prejudiced against the Jewish state. It also reflected a feckless desire to curry favor with Muslim and Arab-American voters prior to the November presidential election. Much to the dismay of Democrats, that gambit failed. Many of them chose not to vote for Vice President Kamala Harris against Trump largely out of spite because they and others in his party’s left-wing intersectional base deemed Biden, who zigzagged between support for the Jewish state’s right of self-defense and harsh criticism of its exercise of that right, insufficiently anti-Israel.

No matter his motivation, the mixed signals sent by Biden, and later by Harris as well, about the war only served to encourage Hamas to refuse to negotiate seriously. Rather than acknowledge defeat and end the suffering of the Palestinian population of Gaza that they used as pawns and human shields, the terrorists stuck to their demands that a ceasefire would entail a return to the pre-Oct. 7 status quo, where they would be in charge in Gaza. And they did this while claiming that it was Israel’s fault for refusing to surrender to them.

Sadly, that false claim has been echoed by some of Netanyahu’s domestic political opponents. The anti-Bibi resistance largely hijacked the cause of the hostage families. These partisans have sought to place all the blame for their remaining in captivity on the prime minister who had to balance their plight against his obligation not to endanger other Israelis by paying a price for their freedom that would lead to more Oct. 7-like assaults.

While Israelis remain deeply divided about Netanyahu, there’s no sign that this debate extends to his policy of carrying the war to Hamas and Hezbollah. There is a broad consensus that Hamas cannot be allowed to threaten Israel again. And there will be no way to do that if the Israel Defense Forces don’t maintain a presence inside the Gaza Strip even after the mopping up of the remaining Palestinian terrorists is eventually finished.

Biden stiffened Hamas’s resolve

Whether they intended to or not, Biden’s and Harris’s often severe criticism of Israel’s conduct of the war as being too harsh or resulting in too many Palestinian casualties only stiffened the resolve of the remnants of Hamas and other terrorist movements in Gaza. Combined with their continuing desire to appease rather than to confront Iran and their ineffectual response to the terrorist attacks being conducted by their Hezbollah and Houthi proxy forces, the administration’s pressure on Israel made the goal of a hostage deal at any price even less likely.

Iran is key to solving this puzzle, as is the behavior of Turkey and Qatar, the Gulf state that is a major supporter of Hamas and Tehran while also playing the hand of serving as an American ally. Hamas’s remaining cadres are confident that as long as they retain foreign support, they need not consider giving up a hopeless struggle not just to hold onto parts of Gaza but to eventually destroy Israel.

Yet everything Biden has done in the Middle East has been tainted by his administration’s ongoing desire to avoid antagonizing Iran. That was reflected in their attitudes towards Hezbollah’s control of Lebanon and their warnings to Israel to avoid strikes on Iran’s nuclear program or its ability to ship oil even after Tehran directly attacked Israel twice in 2024. This is a policy that everyone on Biden’s team has treated as a priority dating back to their time working for President Barack Obama and his efforts to achieve a rapprochement with Tehran while creating more “daylight” between Washington and Jerusalem.

Sending a warning

Trump’s threats may not be enough to convince Hamas to give up their fight to hang on in Gaza. But they have given the Iranians, as well as Qatar and Turkey, a lot to think about. Whether or not they succeed in the short term, the president-elect has served notice to the region that those who have enabled the continuation of the war on Israel that began last Oct. 7 may be forced to pay a very high price for continuing to do so.

What does that mean?

Certainly, it will entail a return to the “maximum pressure” campaign on Iran that Trump employed to bring its economy to its knees before he left office in January 2021. Their plight was only relieved by Biden’s foolish lifting of sanctions on Tehran and transferring billions of dollars in formerly frozen funds to the Islamist regions. But the ayatollahs and their Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps shock troops must also worry about the threat of a “green light” from Trump to Israel to take out their nuclear program and capacity to ship oil to foreign customers who are keeping the regime afloat.

It is also a warning to Qatar and Turkey that they, too, might suffer from Trump’s disfavor.

Rather than being a weakness, Trump’s blunt talk on issues of foreign policy, coupled with his unpredictability and unwillingness to brook insults from rogue states, are some of his greatest strengths when operating on the international scene. It is also crucial to understanding why events such as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, as well as the Oct. 7 attacks enabled by Iran, didn’t happen on Trump’s watch.

Moreover, it was also Trump’s moral clarity on the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians that led to his success in expanding the circle of peace via the Abraham Accords. Only by making it crystal clear that Israel had America’s full backing could Muslim and Arab nations be persuaded to drop their resistance to normalizing relations with the Jewish state. Rather than set the region on fire, Trump’s move of the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem—plus the recognition of Israeli sovereignty on the Golan, the legality of Jewish communities in Judea and Samaria, and by holding the Palestinian Authority accountable for their support for terrorism—brought the region closer to peace.

More threats, less appeasement

Some people are put off by Trump’s bluster and disinterest in diplomatic niceties. But it is precisely a return to his unorthodox style that enabled him to ignore the advice of the foreign-policy establishment and its self-styled “experts” who have been wrong about the Middle East for decades.

What the world needs is more Trumpian threats and less of Biden’s blind faith in multilateralism, appeasement of Iran and diplomacy for its own sake. Whether or not his demand for the prompt release of hostages held captive for a full 14 months, including a baby, is heeded, his return to the White House is good news for supporters of Israel. It’s also a reason for those who have been enabling the terrorists to reconsider their vile and ultimately foolish stand.

PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH WAS DEAD WRONG ..... AND SO IS BIDEN

Has Israel repeated the mistake of 2006 with its ceasefire?

Unlike Hamas to the south, Hezbollah has not been destroyed; it continues to exert influence over the country, and Iran can quickly rebuild it. 

 

By Mitchell Bard

 

JNS

Dec 4, 2024

 

 

File:2006 Lebanon War. XV.jpg

Israeli forces operating in Lebanon during the Second Lebanon War, Aug. 12, 2006

 

The 2006 Israel-Lebanon war mirrored the current war in Gaza in terms of the U.S. and international reaction to the civilian casualties and displacement of large numbers of people. Like President Joe Biden, President George W. Bush initially opposed a ceasefire. “He believes that the Israelis have a right to protect themselves,” Bush spokesman Tony Snow said, “and also that we think it’s important that in doing that they try to limit as much as possible so-called collateral damage, not only to facilities but also to human lives.” Snow added, “The president is not going to make military decisions for Israel.”

A month later, however, the president changed his tune. He was angered by what he saw as Israeli indifference to the death toll and international opinion. As today, he feared that the war could escalate and alienate America’s Arab allies. Another concern was that Hezbollah would gain influence because Israel could not achieve a decisive military victory.

Bush obtained support for U.N. Security Council Resolution 1701 to create “an effective international force to deploy to Lebanon,” which he said was “essential to the freedom of Lebanon.” After Israel withdrew its troops, this force would “help the Lebanese army meet its responsibility to secure Lebanon’s borders and stop … Hezbollah from acting as a state within a state.” Furthermore, he reassured everyone, “An effective international force will help give displaced people in both Lebanon and Israel the confidence to return to their homes and begin rebuilding their lives without fear of renewed violence and terror.”

Bush said the “root cause of the problem … was you have a state within a state. You have people launch attacks on a sovereign nation without the consent of the government in the country in which they are lodged.” He said it was imperative that Lebanon “exert control over the entire country” and that an international force “make sure that the Hezbollah forces don’t rearm, don’t get arms from Syria or Iran through Syria, to be able to continue to wreak havoc in the region.”

He and other officials, notably Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, repeatedly used the word “robust” to describe the international force that would be created to keep the peace. “The language [of the resolution] says that anything and anyone who keeps them from fulfilling their responsibilities is to be challenged on that, and they even have the right to use force if they need to,” Rice said. “That mandate was written in a very robust fashion.”

That force, the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), was to be 15,000-strong.

“One thing is for certain,” Bush said, “when this force goes into help Lebanon, Hezbollah won’t have that safe haven or that kind of freedom to run in Lebanon’s southern border… Hopefully, over time, Hezbollah will disarm. You can’t have a democracy with an armed political party willing to bomb its neighbor without the consent of its government, or deciding, well, let’s create enough chaos and discord by lobbing rockets.”

Interestingly, while in one breath he talked about a force that would enforce the resolution calling for the disarming of Hezbollah, in the next, he expressed the hope it would disarm.

The new ceasefire agreement calls for the deployment of 10,000 Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF) to the southern border, in addition to the UNIFIL force that has consistently failed to be “robust” over the past 18 years.

“An international force requires international commitment,” Bush said and promised to assist “with logistic support, command and control, communications and intelligence.”

Sound familiar?

The Biden White House said, “Our job will be to receive complaints of violations and provide training and support to the LAF.” Unlike 2006, an official claimed, when “the international community reached the agreement and then abandoned the scene, here we remain committed to be on the ground day to day, watch what’s happening, and to let everybody know, whether it’s Hezbollah or other terrorist organizations, that the world is watching.”

The world watched from 2006 until the day the ceasefire was signed and did nothing. The official acknowledged that UNIFIL failed in its mission to enforce the ceasefire and yet UNIFIL will be expected to enforce the new agreement. In both a nod to political reality and an unwillingness to literally put skin in the game, no U.S. combat troops will participate.

Bush acknowledged that Iran and Syria were “working to thwart the efforts of the Lebanese people to break free from foreign domination and build their own democratic future. The terrorists and their sponsors are not going to succeed. The Lebanese people have made it clear they want to live in freedom. And now it’s up to their friends and allies to help them do so.”

Again, neither Bush nor his successors took any action against Iran or Syria.

Biden said “this deal supports Lebanon’s sovereignty and so it heralds the new start for Lebanon” that “can put Lebanon on a path toward a future that’s worthy of a significant past.”

Is there any reason to believe the outcome will differ from when Bush said the same thing?

The new ceasefire agreement reiterates Resolution 1701’s requirement for the “disarmament of all armed groups in Lebanon” but does not require the LAF to take any action against Hezbollah troops deployed north of the Litani River. It only requires the prevention of future smuggling of weapons into Lebanon. Only Hezbollah installations south of the river are mentioned for dismantling.

So why did Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu agree to the ceasefire?

Israel asserts while the U.S. denies that the Biden administration threatened to block further weapons deliveries and would not veto another U.N. ceasefire resolution. Just a week earlier, Netanyahu had boasted of repeatedly defying Biden; however, this time, he acknowledged that Israel needed its weapons resupplied. After agreeing to the ceasefire, Netanyahu said the issue was resolved, and the administration subsequently announced a $680 million arms sale to replenish precision weapons depleted during the war.

When Bush discussed the 2006 ceasefire, he also referenced the geopolitical situation that is relevant today. “I remember right after Hezbollah launched its rocket attacks on Israel, I said, this is a clarifying moment. It’s a chance for the world to see the threats of the 21st century, the challenge we face,” Bush said on Aug. 21, 2006.

But the world did not see it that way. Hezbollah was allowed to build up its arsenal to the point where it threatened not only Israel but regional stability.

Bush also recognized the Iranian threat. “They encourage a radical brand of Islam. Imagine how difficult this issue would be if Iran had a nuclear weapon,” Bush said. He thought the danger could be managed through the U.N., which passed a Security Council resolution demanding Iran cease its enrichment activities.

He was wrong again. A decade later, the Iranian nuclear threat had grown to the point that President Barack Obama negotiated a deal to halt its progress towards acquiring a bomb. That deal failed, as did Trump’s “maximum pressure” campaign and Biden’s appeasement strategy. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) now reports that Iran has enriched uranium to 32 times the amount allowed under that agreement and could produce multiple atomic bombs if its stockpile is further enriched to weapons-grade levels.

There should have never been any doubt that the war in Lebanon would end on Biden’s terms. As I wrote last November, presidents, and not prime ministers, end Israeli wars. Netanyahu capitulated but, predictably, claimed victory even though Hezbollah was not destroyed (a tiny fraction of its forces was killed), it continues to exert influence over the country, and Iran can quickly rebuild it.

Israel does derive short-term benefits: saving the lives of soldiers, the acceleration of U.S. weapons deliveries, the opportunity to focus on Iran and finish off Hamas, and getting a desperately needed respite for reservists. It is not clear, however, that the ceasefire achieved the war’s objective of allowing the residents of the north to return to their homes, given that Hezbollah was firing more than 100 rockets a day before the ceasefire and could do so again at any time.

Israel has a better claim to victory in the south. The IDF has killed most Hamas terrorists, and the survivors are no longer firing rockets. As in the north, however, the American president will determine the outcome. President-elect Donald Trump has made it clear that he wants the war to end before he is inaugurated. There will be a heavy price, but Netanyahu will likely comply to avoid Trump’s wrath.

POLLS HAVE SHOWN THAT MOST AFRICAN-AMERICANS HARBOR ANTISEMITIC VIEWS

How to take down black antisemites like Ta-Nehisi Coates

A self-proclaimed advocate for blacks everywhere, the writer ignores the ongoing brutal Islamic “holy war” in at least nine African countries. 

 

By Charles Jacobs and Ben Poser

 

JNS

Dec 4, 2024

 

Tony-Dokoupil-Coates-cbs

CBS News anchor Tony Dokoupil (R) interviews Ta-Nehisi Coates about his new book “The Message” on September 30, 2024

 

Ta-Nehisi Coates masquerades as a champion of black people, but the reality is that he is enabling the work of their enemies.

As a self-proclaimed advocate for African-Americans, Coates ignores the ongoing brutal Islamic “holy war” in at least nine African countries—Burkina Faso, Cameroon, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Mali, Mozambique, Niger, Nigeria, Somalia and Sudan—where Arabs and African Muslims are regularly murdering, raping and taking non-Muslim or un-Arabized Africans as slaves.

Coates cannot mention these atrocities because it would undermine his central argument—that only white oppressors are victimizing brown and black people everywhere. His decision to disregard these theaters of jihad is a deceit, an evasion that erases the moral superiority that has earned him such public acclaim and deference.

In his new book, The Message, Coates maps his simple formula onto Israeli Jews whom he casts as “white” oppressors abusing non-white Palestinians. When CBS News censured its own (Jewish) news anchor, Tony Dokoupil, for pushing back against Coates during a discussion of his book, the ensuing controversy focused on whether the network should subject writers “of color” to journalistic challenges.

There is a more urgent matter: Dokoupil’s defense of Israel didn’t work. While Dokoupil pointed out how Coates evaded the complexities of the conflict and omitted facts that supported Israel’s position, the average audience member was more likely swayed by his simple portrait of Israel as a racist society than by Dokoupil’s efforts to insert context.

Responding to defamatory claims against Israel with myth-busters about the conflict remains the semi-official Jewish method of response to anti-Israel slander. It has always failed as new lies just keep coming—first, the Jews stole the land, they defeated Arab armies only because America helped them, then they stole water, and now they commit genocide. Opposing misinformation alone has failed spectacularly, just look at what’s happening on college campuses and in city streets. Yet even today, the pro-Israel pamphlets distributed to Jewish students on campus follow the prescription: “Countering the Lies.”

This strategy fails because it is exclusively defensive. While refuting lies is a necessity, it is only a first step. As in war, the best defense is a strong offense. The Arab world has more to answer for regarding every charge thrown at Israel: conquest, imperialism, subjugation of minorities and the flagrant abuse of basic human rights. The myth-busting strategy never calls out the liars and never turns the charges back against them. Instead, it locks Israel’s defenders in the dock as the accused and has them spending time trying to refute one libel after another. Dokoupil’s interventions, while good and well-delivered, cannot prevail against a torrent of lies.

Judaism teaches that a primary goal of life is to achieve the highest moral conduct possible. Hyper-scrutiny of Jewish conduct is normal Jewish practice. Jewish consciousness questions Jewish conduct continually. So when Jewish behavior is singled out for criticism by their foes—not to improve but to harm them—old Jewish habits have them starting on the defense. “Are we doing what they say?” comes naturally, but “Who are you to accuse?” does not. Yet the key to winning rhetorical battles is to turn the fire back on your accuser.

Leftist and human-rights groups are seen as moral actors due to their reputation as fighters for the oppressed, the marginalized and the abused. It is this reputation of virtue that protects them from the charge of antisemitism when they focus on Israel and the plight of the Palestinians. Even blatant hostility to Israel is assumed to be a natural extension of their good works.

But they have an insoluble problem: The values of the rights community and the progressive left—the rights of women, the LGBTQ community, freedom of speech and religion—are anathema to the Muslim world. By hyper-focusing on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, they are effectively abandoning the people they are pledged to support and would be expected to champion—those minorities who must pay the price of living under draconian Islamic rule.

As the left has abandoned their original clients to focus on Israel, their claim of acting for social justice can be exposed as fraud. How dare they abandon the gays, the women, the besieged African Christians in the Muslim world. Who are they if they do this?

When Jews respond to attacks on Israel by citing Muslim oppression of these minorities, Israel’s detractors accuse them of engaging in “what-aboutism” by trying to distract from the issue at hand: Jewish conduct. But why should this be the issue at hand? Had the rights community been honest from the start, Muslim oppression of minorities would have been a major target decades ago. The answer to “what-aboutism” is clear: “Are you abandoning black jihad slaves so that you can hit at the Jews or are you campaigning against the Jews to hide Islamist savagery?”

For black antisemites to abandon their African sisters and brothers is egregious. They are turning their backs on their own. Black Jew-haters like Coates, Louis Farrakhan and Marc Lamont Hill—even conservative ones like Candance Owens— ignore the tragedy of blacks murdered and enslaved by Muslims in Africa so they can identify with Arab Muslims against the Jewish state.

Coates claims that it is natural and right to side with the Palestinians because they, like blacks in America, are oppressed by “whites.” To say this, Coates must forget that more than half of Israel’s population are darker-skinned Jews, who are native to the Middle East. Worse, he must deny Muslim mass murder and enslavement of African blacks.

He must obscure the truth that these black victims of jihad are subjected to continuous, brutal violence mirrored in Hamas’s rape and slaughter of Jews. Like the Israelis, burned, hacked and shot to death a year ago, the Africans that Coates ignore suffer the same fate, dragged from their homes and taken hostage. In Algeria, Libya and Mauritania, blacks are trafficked as both grunt and sex slaves, and in the case of Mauritania, owned, like Coates’s own ancestors, as true chattel.

How should defenders of Israel respond to the Coateses of this world?

Here is an opening suggestion: “Mr. Coates you cannot be ignorant of the jihad surging across Africa. Nearly a third of a million black slaves are in Muslim hands today. You cannot be blind to the parallel atrocities committed by jihadists in Nigeria and the jihadist rapes, murders, and abductions of young Jewish women on Oct. 7. Muslim jihadists have been massacring blacks for 1,400 years—including the descendants of the ancient Nubians, from whose language your own name is borrowed. Where is your outrage? Who better than you should lead an effort to emancipate them from servitude and stop the murders?”

The same approach can be applied to a variety of our foes on the left.

To women’s rights groups: “Women in Israel have full rights, but in the Muslim world, they are oppressed. How can you keep silent about crimes against women in Muslim societies while you attack the one country in the Middle East where women are liberated?”

To LGBQT groups: “LGBTQ individuals live freely in Israel. In the Muslim world, they are persecuted, tortured and executed. Why are you silent about their plight in Muslim countries? They will never forgive you.”

To Democrats: “All Muslim countries are ruled by dictators and autocrats whose rule is enforced by brute power. In what democratic universe do activists remain silent about regimes that jail journalists, murder opponents and have no genuine elections?”

For Black Lives Matter and other black groups: “You see Muslims in America as ‘intersectional’ allies because they are, like you, minorities here. But why extend your alliance to their brethren in Africa who are not minorities but the oppressors of minorities and who murder and enslave blacks in Africa? Have you asked Muslims here for their help in liberating Muslim-held slaves in Africa? Where are your public protests against Boko Haram in Nigeria and the Rapid Support Forces in Sudan?

Jewish concern cannot be solely to advance Jewish interests. Africans need American Jews to advocate for them, to scream about their plight, and to organize against their slaughter and enslavement. Some of us have begun to do this very Jewish work.

SUBVERSION? ..... I WOULD CALL IT TRASON

Bogie’s subversion isn’t so surprising

Israelis shocked by the former defense chief’s lies about “ethnic cleansing” in Gaza haven’t been paying attention to how radical he's become. 

 

By Ruthie Blum

 

JNS

Dec 2, 2024

 

Moshe ("Bogie") Ya'alon leading an anti-government protest on Israel Independence Day, Tel Aviv, April 25, 2023. Photo by Avshalom Sassoni/Flash90.
Moshe ("Bogie") Ya'alon leading an anti-government protest on Israel Independence Day, Tel Aviv, April 25, 2023.
 

In a “Shabbat of Culture” interview with Lucy Aharish on DemocratTV, former Israeli defense minister Moshe (“Bogie”) Ya’alon bolstered enemy propaganda without batting an eyelash. His performance was so helpful to the likes of Hamas and Hezbollah that it made headlines all over the Arabic-language media.

There’s no doubt that the International Criminal Court is celebrating, as well. Nor is it unreasonable to assume that ICC chief prosecutor Karim Khan is adding Bogie’s mendacious statements to the already bogus indictments of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin “Bibi” Netanyahu and former defense minister Yoav Gallant for alleged “crimes against humanity.”

Ditto regarding the International Court of Justice, which could easily include Bogie’s words in its upcoming ruling on Israel’s “genocide” in Gaza. After all, the former chief of the Israel Defense Forces is nothing if not an expert on IDF behavior. And his various political roles only add weight to the authority of his rank.

“The current path we’re being dragged down involves conquering, annexing and carrying out ethnic cleansing,” he told Aharish on Saturday. “Look at northern Gaza: transfer, call it what you want, and settling it with Jewish communities. That’s the issue.”

He went on, “Now, if you look at the polls, 70% of the Israeli public, sometimes more, supports a path that is Jewish, democratic, liberal and so on, including separation [from the Palestinians]. So, we must not be confused here. Those trying to confuse us are leading us toward nothing less than destruction.”

An astonished Aharish replied, “You just used a phrase I never thought I’d hear from you: ‘ethnic cleansing’ in the Gaza Strip. Is that really what you think? That we’re heading in that direction?”

Ya’alon replied, “Why ‘heading’? Look at what’s happening there. There’s no Beit Lahiya, no Beit Hanoun. Right now, operations are underway in Jabalia, essentially clearing the area of Arabs.”

The justified national outrage at the bald-faced lie was immediate. There is no “ethnic cleansing” taking place in Gaza. The temporary displacement of residents has been carried out to protect them from IDF operations against Hamas and its infrastructure.

Indeed, at great risk to the troops—who are fighting terrorists while searching for the 101 hostages still held by sadistic captors in subterranean dungeons and private homes—the Israeli military continues to take every possible precaution to avoid civilian casualties. It does this by informing the populace, with fliers and phone calls, of the location of imminent airstrikes.

As a result, the ratio of non-combatant-to-terrorist deaths is historically low. It’s an especially impressive feat, given the precarious conditions of the dense urban battlefield above ground and massive tunnel network below.

Anger, thus, wasn’t the only reaction to Bogie’s remarks. Shock was even more prevalent, particularly when he doubled down the following morning.

“I am speaking on behalf of commanders serving in northern Gaza,” he told Kan Reshet Bet radio’s Aryeh Golan on Sunday morning. “War crimes are being committed here. I stand by this term. IDF soldiers are being put in harm’s way, and they will be exposed to lawsuits at the International Criminal Court.”

Yes, thanks to the likes of Bogie, the brave, conscionable men and women who’ve spent the past 14 months safeguarding their country—after it suffered the worst atrocities against Jews since the Holocaust—are all the more likely to be targets of antisemitic lawfare.

Horrified and saddened, those who served with or under Bogie’s command in previous wars haven’t been able to wrap their heads around his betrayal. Though aware of his gradual repudiation of his right-wing views (i.e. opposition to Israel’s disengagement from Gaza in 2005 and support for Jewish settlement in Judea and Samaria)—and of his anti-Netanyahu activism—they seem to have been in denial about how radical he’d actually grown.

Resorting to psychological explanations for his transformation, some head-scratchers are chalking it up to a combination of resentment and envy toward Netanyahu, beginning in 2016. That was when he resigned from his post as defense minister, citing “difficult disagreements [with Netanyahu] on moral and professional matters,” and warning that “extreme and dangerous elements have taken over Israel and the Likud Party [of which Bogie was a member].”

The truth is that Netanyahu was replacing him with Yisrael Beiteinu leader Avigdor Liberman, whose condition for joining the coalition—expanding it from 61 to 67 seats—was to receive the defense portfolio.

Though Netanyahu was considering consoling Bogie with the job of foreign minister, the latter quit in a huff. He spent the following years trying to defeat Bibi, first by forming his own party, Telem, and subsequently by merging it in 2019 with the parties run by Benny Gantz and Yair Lapid to create a new bloc called “Blue and White.”

Failing to realize his fantasy of ruining his nemesis, Netanyahu, and after four rounds of Knesset elections that ended in an impasse, he retired from politics in 2021, before Lapid and Naftali Bennett concocted a short-lived rotation government.

Bogie found his calling when Netanyahu became prime minister at the end of 2022 and the government began proceedings to reform the judicial system. A key leader of the protest movement, which grew uglier with each passing week, Bogie became the darling of the woke bleeding hearts who not long ago wouldn’t have given him the time of day, let alone the benefit of the doubt.

One such figure is Nava Rozolyo—a lawyer, accountant, Pilates instructor, vegan and founder of the “Shame Guard Corps”—with whom he recently shared a protest podium and beaming selfie. She, like Bogie, refers to Bibi as an illegitimate “dictator.”

Among other charming activities, the Shame Guard Corps shows up at the homes of coalition members and harasses them. In an Oct. 29 interview with the far-left podcast Hamutzim, Rozolyo said that the purpose of the protest movement is to provide wind for the sails of the gatekeepers with the power to topple the government. These include: the defense establishment, the judiciary, the attorney general, courageous journalists and the Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency). In addition, she said, the point is to reach out to foreign governments and the tribunals at The Hague—you know, the ICC and ICJ.

Rozolyo is chummy with Yair Golan, leader of the new hybrid Labor-Meretz party, the Democrats. Golan is the former deputy IDF chief who took the opportunity of Holocaust Remembrance Day in 2016 to tell soldiers he was seeing signs of the processes that occurred in Nazi Germany “among us today.”

Bogie, it should be noted, defended him against his detractors—and that was eight years ago.

His metamorphosis may be jaw-dropping for people who used to admire him. But their attributing it merely to Bibi-aversion—as delusional a syndrome as it’s proven to be—means they weren’t grasping the depths of his ideological conversion.

A MOUSE FART OR A TSUNAMI ?

By Bob Walsh


President Joe Biden greets his son Hunter Biden at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago, Illinois, on Aug. 19, 2024.

 

It has now been a few days since Senile Joe wrote his son an unprecedented, wide-ranging get-out-of-jail-free card.  His move blew up in the face of many of his supporters who had been crowing about how wonderful he was for refusing to pardon his son and how this demonstrated his commitment to the rule of law.  So, what will the fallout be?

My suspicion, for what that might be worth to you, is that it is going to be considerable on both the short and medium term.

A lot of people are responding, "So What.  He lied.  All politicians lie.  It is to be expected."  Others are responding that he legitimately changed his mind.  (Kind of like his decision to stay in the race then bail out.  I wonder if Hunter left a metaphorical horses head in Joe's bed.)  Joe's statement, which seems to blame his own DOJ for being unfair to Hunter, is being largely ignored as nonsensical.  A few (damn few) are making noises that they now think Joe is a hypocritical turd and that this move by him will pretty much destroy his legacy and will make it much, much harder for them to oppose Trump in what will probably be his actions towards the January 6 "insurrectionists."  

One thing for sure, Joe has lost the moral high ground not only for himself but to a large extent for his party as well.  Will this matter in two years?   Will it matter in four years?  Yeah, I think it will. 

MURDERER ESCAPES IN SUNNY CALIFORNIA

By Bob Walsh

 

PHOTO: Cesar Hernandez, 34


Cesar Hernandez, 34, managed to escape custody while he was being transported from prison in Kern County to the county courthouse for a weapons charge.  He was doing 25-life for murder.

The cops put out a decent search arrangement promptly, which included stopping and searching cars in the area.  So far he has not been located though they did find the "chains" (presumably waist chains with hand cuffs attached, or maybe leg irons, or maybe both) in an alley near the courthouse.

As someone who used to do these transports I find it difficult to understand this.  Allegedly the guy just managed to bail out of the vehicle and run.  The doors of the transport vehicle should not have been able to be opened from the inside.  He should have been wearing both a waist chain and leg irons.  If nothing else the transport crew, which should have been at least two officers and possibly a chase vehicle, should have bailed out and shot his happy ass.  

I expect somebody will have some explaining to do.  Of course since I have been retired for nearly 20 years it is distinctly possible that staff are now discouraged from shooting fleeing murderers.  They do things strange in California.

CA LIMITS LEGISLATION

By Bob Wash



The legislature of the formerly great state of California has passed new, more restrictive limits on the amount of legislation that members are allow to propose in each year.  The 80 members of the assembly are allowed to propose 35 bills each per year.  The 40 members of the senate are similarly allowed 35 new bills per year.  This is a rule of the legislature and not a law and can be ignored anytime the leadership of the legislature feels like ignoring it.  

Even the arrogant and self-centered members of the legislature have recognized that they are burying themselves in work.  

The legislature of CA is in session pretty much year around and has been for many, many years.

DOESN'T EVERYONE IN TEXAS OWN A GUN ANY MORE ?

By Bob Walsh



 
If the news is to be believed the citizens of Cleveland, Texas are living in fear of feral dogs roaming around their streets attacking animals and pets with impunity.

There is unfortunately no formalized animal control operation in Liberty County.  The dogs often roam in packs attacking pretty much at will.  The S. O. has suggested that residents just shoot threatening dogs.  Seems reasonable to me.  Dogs can be mean, but they are not bullet proof.  I can't imagine there are so many that two or three honest citizens who just happened to be taking a walk while armed could not handle whatever came at them and that after two or three such encounters the problem should be greatly reduced.
 
EDITOR'S NOTE: At least one person did shoot at the dogs but missed.

SHE DIDN'T FLIP ONE COUNTY. NOT ONE.

By Bob Walsh

 

a woman says " what can be unburdened by what has been " while smiling

 

Kamala did not flip a single county from red to blue during the recent election.  Not one.  That is the first time that has happened since 1932.  That's pretty bad when you are running against Hitler.

Tuesday, December 03, 2024

HUNTER BIDEN'S PROBLEMS - AND SEEMINGLY THOSE OF HIS FAMILY - MAY BE FAR FROM OVER

The bombshell hidden detail in Biden's Hunter pardon that means it could BACKFIRE and spark a catastrophe for the entire family, revealed by ALAN DERSHOWITZ

 

By Alan Dershowitz 


Daily Mail

Dec 3, 2024


President Joe Biden's extraordinarily broad pardon of his son may have saved Hunter from a prison sentence, but it might actually mark the beginning of worse legal troubles for the Biden clan.

President Joe Biden's extraordinarily broad pardon of his son may have saved Hunter from a prison sentence, but it might actually mark the beginning of worse legal troubles for the Biden clan. 

 

President Joe Biden's extraordinarily broad pardon of his son may have saved Hunter from a prison sentence, but it might actually mark the beginning of worse legal troubles for the Biden clan.

By pre-emptively shielding Hunter from the consequences of any alleged criminal conduct dating back eleven years, the President leaves his son open to virtually unlimited questioning in future Congressional, civil or even criminal investigations.

That's because Hunter Biden can no longer claim the privilege of the Fifth Amendment – a Constitutional right that protects people from offering testimony that may incriminate them.

Since Hunter is now effectively immune from federal prosecution, he cannot plausibly claim that testimony could constitute self-incrimination.

That makes Hunter a potential key witness for years to come.

Biden's blanket pardon is, in fact, a gift to President-elect Donald Trump's attorney general nominee Pam Bondi, should she ever choose to look into allegations that the Biden family has corruptly profited off foreign influence peddling for decades.

One Republican-led House committee has estimated that the Bidens and their business associates have raked in more than $27 million in overseas business deals in recent years. However, not a single Biden family member has ever registered as a 'foreign agent' as may be required by law.

That seems like fertile ground for investigation.

It's true that prosecutions of those who fail to report their work for foreign governments have been rare. But that's changed in recent years.

In July, Senator Bob Menendez was convicted for, among other charges, failing to declare himself as a foreign agent for Egypt.

On the first day of the new administration, Bondi, a former Florida AG, will be free to convene a grand jury and start her investigations.

Indeed, investigators likely have many questions for a political family that has become fabulously rich operating in close proximity to power.

Hunter may be asked what Biden knew about the son's foreign business deals while he was reportedly hitching rides on Air Force Two while Joe was serving as Barack Obama's Vice President.

Hunter allegedly accompanied his dad at least 13 times on trips to China, Egypt, Mexico and South Korea while Biden was VP.

Another topic of interest may be what Biden said when he attended dinners and joined phone calls with Hunter's business associates during that period.

Or what Hunter meant when he wrote in an email to his sister, Ashley Biden, that 'pop' takes 'half his salary'.

Perhaps most critically, Bondi may probe the true identity of the infamous 'Big Guy,' so characterized in the ownership documents for Oneida Holdings, a now-dissolved firm owned by Hunter Biden, his ex-business associate Tony Bobulinski and others.

Bobulinski provided hearsay testimony to Congress this year that the 'Big Guy' was Joe Biden, who he claimed requested a cut of the profits of Onedia Holdings.

Two IRS whistleblowers involved in a federal investigation of Hunter's tax case have also said that Biden was the 'Big Guy'.

While this pardon immunizes Hunter from federal prosecution, it does not protect him from civil litigation, including possible fraud charges. 

 

Hunter Biden can no longer claim the privilege of the Fifth Amendment - a Constitutional right that protects people from offering testimony that may incriminate them.

Hunter Biden can no longer claim the privilege of the Fifth Amendment - a Constitutional right that protects people from offering testimony that may incriminate them. 

A topic of interest may be what VP Biden said when he attended dinners and joined phone calls with Hunter's business associates. Or what Hunter meant when he wrote in an email to his sister, Ashley Biden (pictured in between Joe and Jill), that 'pop' takes 'half his salary'.

A topic of interest may be what VP Biden said when he attended dinners and joined phone calls with Hunter's business associates. Or what Hunter meant when he wrote in an email to his sister, Ashley Biden (pictured in between Joe and Jill), that 'pop' takes 'half his salary'.

 

New York Attorney General Letitia James went after Trump for inflating his real estate assets and obtained a nearly half-billion-dollar civil judgment against him.

Might incoming Trump officials now follow her politically-minded lead?

President-elect Trump publicly expressed sympathy for Hunter in the waning days of the 2024 campaign and reportedly said as much privately when meeting with Biden at the White House after the election. This may incline his administration to be lenient with the outgoing president's son – but it's not a guarantee.

And if Hunter is subpoenaed by Congress to testify against family members that opens up a terrible can of legal worms.

Hunter will face several options, few of which are particularly appealing.

Firstly, his lawyers may concoct an argument that he is still due his Fifth Amendment protections because the President's pardon only protects Hunter from federal charges, leaving him vulnerable to potential state charges which, therefore, makes him capable of self-incrimination.

But that's a weak legal argument. The statutes of limitations on any state tax and gun charges tied to the federal charges he was convicted on this year are bound to have expired.

Secondly, Hunter could defy the subpoena, though I wouldn't recommend that course of action.

Former Trump White House chief strategist Steve Bannon just completed a four-month sentence for refusing to appear before a congressional committee investigating the January 6 riots at the U.S. Capitol.

Thirdly, Hunter could agree to testify and then lie. Of course, this is the least likely scenario and I have no reason to believe that Hunter has anything to lie about.

But, hypothetically at least, that, too, would be a bad choice. Former Trump fixer Michael Cohen found out the hard way when he was sentenced to two-months in prison for committing perjury in his 2017 Senate testimony regarding Trump's business dealings in Russia.

 

President-elect Trump expressed sympathy for Hunter in the waning days of the 2024 election and reportedly in meetings with President Biden at the White House after the election.

President-elect Trump expressed sympathy for Hunter in the waning days of the 2024 election and reportedly in meetings with President Biden at the White House after the election.

 

Finally, Hunter could tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

The consequences of that are still unclear.

The post-presidency outcome for the Biden family is fraught, to say the least.

But the tragedy of it all is that this conundrum could have been avoided if President Biden had waited until Hunter was sentenced for his tax offenses this month and then commuted that punishment. A commuted, rather than pardoned, defendant retains the right to plead the Fifth.

But one thing is certain: Hunter Biden's problems – and seemingly those of his family – may be far from over.

ANYTHING OTHER THAN AN ACQUITTAL WILL BE A CRIME ..... PENNY WAS ONLY CHARGED BECAUSE NEELY WAS BLACK

The VERY telling question Daniel Penny jury asked within an hour of deliberations that may hint at verdict

 

By Joe Hutchison and Brittany Chain 


Daily Mail

Dec 3, 2024


A little over an hour after deliberations started, the jury of seven women and five men, seen here, asked for a readback of a portion of the judge's instructions on justification defenses

A little over an hour after deliberations started, the jury of seven women and five men, seen here, asked for a readback of a portion of the judge's instructions on justification defenses

 

The jury deliberating over the Daniel Penny trial asked for a second read through of what is considered justifiable in the case shortly after being sent out. 

A little over an hour after deliberations started, the jury of seven women and five men asked to again hear a specific portion of the judge's instructions on justification defenses.

They are weighing manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide charges against Daniel Penny who used a fatal chokehold to restrain Jordan Neely on the New York City subway.

To convict, prosecutors say that Penny's use of lethal force must be considered unjustifiable and that he acted recklessly when he subdued Neely to the point of death.

His attorney's argue that Penny, 26, was only trying to protect others in the subway car in May 2023. The Marine veteran has pleaded not guilty to the charges.

After listening to the judge's instructions again, jurors continued deliberations for 90 minutes before heading home for the day without reaching a verdict.

Neely died on the floor of the uptown-bound F train in Manhattan after Penny placed him in a chokehold for six minutes to stop him threatening commuters.

Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran on Tuesday displayed a graphic photo of inside Neely's eye, taken during an autopsy after his death, which shocked the room.

 

Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran repeated the possibility that Penny may not get prison time if he's found guilty. The DA's office has been asking journalists to update their stories throughout the trial to reflect that fact

Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran

They are weighing manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide charges against Daniel Penny, seen here on Tuesday

They are weighing manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide charges against Daniel Penny, seen here on Tuesday 

 

The image was blasted across four screens - two facing the jury, a third facing the viewing gallery and a fourth directly in front of the defendant.

Meanwhile Penny's lawyer tore into the prosecution after journalists were peppered with emails from the DA's office ordering them to include certain details in their stories.

In his closing arguments defense attorney Steven Raiser pointed out no expert witness during the trial could prove key elements beyond reasonable doubt.

He also accused the government of bowing to public pressure, and feeling compelled to make a quick arrest due to the media attention in the case.

Yoran on Tuesday warned the jury their verdict should not rely upon whether they themselves would be grateful for Penny's intervention, or weigh testimony from his loved ones that he is a 'good man.'

'What is so tragic about this case, is that even though the defendant started out doing the right thing… a man died,' she said.

'He was given all the signs he needed to stop. He ignored them. He must be held accountable for that.'

She continued: 'You're not here to decide whether you'd want to ride alone on the train with Jordan Neely.

'That is not what this case is about. The only thing you need to determine here is whether or not the evidence here proves the defendant killed Jordan Neely.'

 

Penny is pictured holding Jordan Neely in a chokehold on a NYC subway train on May 1 2023

Penny is pictured holding Jordan Neely in a chokehold on a NYC subway train on May 1 2023 

His attorney's argue that Penny, 26, was only trying to protect others in the subway car in May 2023. The Marine veteran has pleaded not guilty to the charges

His attorney's argue that Penny, 26, was only trying to protect others in the subway car in May 2023. The Marine veteran has pleaded not guilty to the charges

Assistant district attorney Dafna Yoran is seen here in here closing arguments addressing the jury in the case on Tuesday

Assistant district attorney Dafna Yoran is seen here in here closing arguments addressing the jury in the case on Tuesday 

 

Yoran implored the jury to find Penny guilty of manslaughter – a charge which carries a maximum term of 15 years behind bars.

She told jurors in great detail how Mr Neely 'clawed at his own neck with his nails' as he fought against the chokehold in those crucial first few minutes, before ultimately urinating on himself and losing consciousness.

She described the negligent homicide charge – the lesser of the two – as essentially a fallback charge which should be applied if the jury is not convinced Penny committed manslaughter.

Sharing footage of Penny standing to the side of the train immediately after ending the chokehold, Yoran asked jurors to consider why he felt comfortable at this point in stepping away.

'Why is he not concerned about that, all of a sudden? Because he knows Mr Neely is no longer a threat. That he is out.

'If the defendant believed that all he had done was render Mr Neely temporarily unconscious, he would have immediately moved to secure him in another way because he would have believed Mr Neely would wake up at any second and either attack someone or run away.

'If he was going to have revived, he would have revived in a matter of seconds. The defendant clearly knows Mr Neely is not waking up any time soon.

'There is only one explanation for that: he knows Mr Neely is not going to wake up. He knows he has eliminated the threat.'

 

Neely, seen here, died on the floor of the uptown-bound F train in Manhattan after Penny placed him in a chokehold for six minutes to stop him threatening commuters

Neely, seen here, died on the floor of the uptown-bound F train in Manhattan after Penny placed him in a chokehold for six minutes to stop him threatening commuters 

NYPD officers on attempt to revive Jordan Neely as he lies on the floor of an F train on May 1

NYPD officers on attempt to revive Jordan Neely as he lies on the floor of an F train on May 1

People protest the death of Jordan Neely in New York City. 

People protest the death of Jordan Neely in New York City, May 5, 2023.

 

Yafna also cited Penny's Marine Corps training, arguing that he should have had a clearer understanding of the risks of his actions given his military experience

Defense attorney Steven Raiser told jurors that closing first put his case at a slight disadvantage – because he would have no further opportunity to respond to the claims Yoran would make in her own closing arguments.

As such, he urged jurors to consider what he and his legal team would say in response if given the opportunity, based on the evidence presented.

He had earlier asked jurors to imagine they themselves were on the train when Neely approached.

Raiser argued that even the state's own expert witnesses couldn't prove key elements beyond reasonable doubt.

'If their own experts have doubt… why shouldn't you?' He asked the 12 jurors who have listened to four weeks of intense testimony.

 

Neely was a Michael Jackson impersonator who was known and recognized in Times Square (pictured in 2009)

Neely was a Michael Jackson impersonator who was known and recognized in Times Square (pictured in 2009)

 

Raiser showed footage of the train carriage and used audio of train doors opening and closing, helping to set the scene he was trying to get jurors to envision.

Raiser described those commuters as 'frozen in fear.' He told jurors there was an obvious reason that there was no footage of Neely's outburst - they were too scared to move.

Raiser quoted experts and witnesses who testified during the trial. He reminded the jurors that Neely was described as being 'severely psychotic cases.

Neely had struggled with depression, schizophrenia and drug use after his mother was strangled during his teen years.  

He also noted that Neely had synthetic drugs in his system and that first responders opted to issue Narcan, used to reverse the effects of opioids, before they administered CPR.

Both charges are felonies. Neither carries mandatory prison time, but both carry the possibility of it - up to 15 years for manslaughter, or four for criminally negligent homicide.

Deliberations will resume Wednesday.