This image was originally published
shortly after the 1967 Six-Day War illustrating an article published by
the black activist group the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee
(SNCC) titled “The Palestine Problem.” Harvard admirers failed to
republish an accompanying image of then-Israeli Defense Minister Moshe
Dayan that depicted him sporting a large Star of David on his chest and
dollar signs on his epaulets.
The Harvard organizations later deleted
the post, with the student groups claiming they had “inadvertently
included an image that played upon antisemitic tropes.” This confession
seems disingenuous and even risible. Still, given the state of
scholarship today, it is possible they were simply uninformed about the
image’s historical roots and implications.
Those implications are profound. The image
intentionally expressed the antisemitic ideology espoused by black
nationalist leader Malcolm X in 1964, six months after he left the
Nation of Islam (NOI). This ideology was based on the concept that
Malcolm X called “Zionist Dollarism.” It is this ideology that most of
the current anti-Israel campus groups have echoed and endorsed in
updated form.
Strangely, interim President of Harvard
Alan M. Garber, who strongly denounced the posts, appeared to be unaware
of the fact that the image conveyed and was intended to represent
Malcolm X’s antisemitic teachings.
The image portrays Zionism, supported by
U.S. capitalism, lynching both a black man and an Arab (a person of
color in today’s lexicon). This coupling was not unprecedented. Malcolm X
and the NOI had always characterized black people and Arabs as
“brothers.” In fact, they cast the Arabs as “foreparents” of the
“so-called Negroes of America.”
Malcolm X always neglected to mention that
over fourteen centuries those “foreparents” enslaved 17 million of his
black African forebears. During his trip to Saudi Arabia in 1959, he
even managed to overlook the slave market operating nearby.
In the same way, campus anti-Israel groups
ignore this elephant in the room. Their chosen narrative cannot
accommodate the fact that people of color can oppress, much less
enslave, black people.
“Zionist Dollarism,” Malcolm X asserted,
is a modern form of evil—“neo-colonialism,” now in the stranglehold of
Zionists. Based on his study of the notorious antisemitic forgery The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,
he concluded that Zionists were proficient in the art of deceit. So, he
claimed that they had designed neo-colonialism to last much longer than
the collapsed European empires. In fact, he taught, the Europeans
“foresaw that the awakening masses … would not submit to their old
methods of ruling through ‘force and fears.’” Thus, Malcolm X claimed,
the Europeans issued the Balfour Declaration and turned their evil
mission over to the crafty Jews, who would rule through subterfuge.
Malcolm X stressed that the “colonialism”
of “the Israeli Zionists … appears to be more ‘benevolent’” and thus
“has fast become even more unshakeable than that of the 19th century
European colonialists.” Distorting the Jewish concept of chosenness, he
then insisted that “Israeli Zionists religiously believed their Jewish
god has chosen them … [to establish] a different form of iron-like rule,
more firmly entrenched even than that of the former European Colonial
Powers.”
Despite strong Jewish involvement in the
civil rights movement, Malcolm X claimed that Jews were only “claiming
to be friends of the black man” so they could derail “the real Black
Revolution.” In fact, he asserted, Jews “sapped the very life-blood of
the so-called Negroes” and were thwarting the uprising of the “22
million colonized Afro-Americans.” Moreover, he instructed, “Israeli
Zionists” had captured and were bleeding out their prey in Africa and
the Middle East. The “Zionist capitalist conspiracy,” entrenched in
“Zionist Israel’s occupation of Arab Palestine,” was making “economic
cripples” of the Arabs.
After the Six-Day War, Malcolm X’s
admirers in SNCC elaborated on this narrative. In “The Palestine
Problem,” SNCC claimed to have exposed the villainous Zionist Jews
directly responsible for neo-colonialism. They had discovered that it
was “the famous European Jews, the Rothschilds, who have long controlled
the wealth of many European nations, [who] were involved in the
original conspiracy with the British to create ‘the state of Israel’” in
order to tighten their grip on Africa and the Middle East.
Like Malcolm X and his current admirers
who preach the doctrine of intersectionality, SNCC stressed the
parallels between the experience of black Americans—who had allegedly
been ghettoized, subjugated and bled dry by American Jews—and the Arabs
and Africans who were supposedly being colonized by “Israeli Zionists.”
American Jews’ wealth, they claimed, was stolen from the pockets of
black Americans and Israel’s wealth was now being stripped from Africans
and Arabs.
Malcolm X, SNCC and their successors at
Harvard said nothing new. They simply updated and racialized the world’s
oldest hatred. Jews and now Zionists and the Jewish state were libeled
as the consummate oppressors. Thus, like many antisemites before them,
they turned Zionism on its head. Instead of the national liberation
movement of the Jewish people, Zionism became the ultimate enslaver.
In 1999, the U.S. issued a postage stamp honoring Malcolm X. The ominous implications went unnoticed.
No comments:
Post a Comment