Bloodied woman bangs on homeowner’s door, gets blown away by shotgun
It would seem to me that this shooting was not justified. I do not see how under the circumstances the shooter could have believed his life was in imminent danger. However, part of the blame falls on the victim for driving drunk and for being under the influence of marijuana.
ANOTHER TRAYVON? WHITE MAN CHARGED IN DOORSTEP DEATH OF BLACK TEEN
AFP
November 15, 2013
A white man who shot a black woman who knocked on his door after a late-night car crash in Michigan was charged with murder Friday in a case that has stirred racial tensions.
The death of Renisha McBride, 19, sparked protests and comparisons to Trayvon Martin, the black teenager whose killing last year at the hands of a neighborhood watch volunteer in Florida provoked a national debate on racism and 'stand your ground' self-defense laws.
Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy insisted she was not influenced by the protests. "We do not make our decisions — ever — on public opinion," she told reporters.
"The charging decision has nothing to do with the race of the parties. Whether it becomes relevant I don't know."
The evidence showed that homeowner Theodore Wafer, 54, shot McBride through a locked screen door after opening the storm door, Worthy said.
McBride had been involved in a car accident in Detroit earlier that evening and witnesses said she left on foot and was "bloodied, disoriented and appeared to be confused," Worthy said.
"Hours later her lifeless body was found by police near the porch of a Dearborn Heights home. She was found with a very large gunshot wound to the face."
Wafer was charged with second degree murder, manslaughter and use of a gun during a felony.
It is unclear how McBride ended up in Dearborn Heights, a mostly white suburb, after leaving predominantly-black Detroit.
A toxicology report found that she was significantly over the legal alcohol level for driving and had marijuana in her system, according to local media.
Wafer's lawyer has said that he thought someone was trying to break into his house when he heard the banging at his door shortly before 4:40 am on November 2 and that he was "justified" in shooting McBride.
He reportedly told police his shotgun went off accidentally.
At an arraignment Friday, defense attorney Mack Carpenter insisted his client would be exonerated.
"My client has a very strong defense of this charge the likelihood of conviction is not that great," Carpenter told the court as Wafer stood with his hands clasped in front of his jeans.
The judge said that due to the "seriousness of the crime" he would set a bond of $250,000.
"We do not believe he acted in lawful self-defense," Worthy said in announcing the charges.
While Michigan law declares there is "no duty to retreat if you're in your own home," Worthy said lawful self-defense requires an "honest and reasonable belief of imminent death or imminent great bodily harm."
McBride was unarmed and there were no signs of forced entry, Worthy said.
Her family welcomed the charges at a press conference.
"We stand with the community, and America, that has spoken out of the unjustness of this murder," mother Monica McBride told reporters.
"She deserves to be here today."
Walter Simmons said his daughter was a hard-working girl who loved cars and dreamed of becoming a nurse or maybe working in Detroit's auto industry.
"She was just beginning," he told reporters. "She could have been anything."
1 comment:
Shooting someone by accident is NEVER justifiable. It is likely he would have been better off saying that he shot her on purpose. Also, shooting someone through an outside door is not usually justifiable, though Michigan does have what I am told is an exceptionally strong stand your ground-castle doctrine law. They were both stupid but that doesn't mean the young woman should have died. Pounding on someones door in the wee hours should not get you shot.
Post a Comment