Experts advise caution about report Christopher Columbus was Jewish
Matt Goldish, of Ohio State, told JNS that the report "may create a perfect storm of Jew-hatred if the same Jews caused the destruction of native American civilization and of native Palestinian civilization.
For many years, guides leading visitors on tours of Jewish history in Spain have shared rumors that Christopher Columbus was Jewish. A new documentary that garnered worldwide press coverage ahead of Columbus Day on Monday states that DNA evidence proves that the explorer was a member of the tribe, but experts told JNS that such a claim should be taken with a grain of salt.
The national Spanish broadcaster TVE aired “Columbus DNA: The true origin” on Saturday, Reuters reported. “Researchers conducted a 22-year investigation, led by forensic expert Miguel Lorente, by testing tiny samples of remains buried in Seville Cathedral, long marked by authorities there as the last resting place of Columbus, though there had been rival claims,” the wire reported.
“We have DNA from Christopher Columbus, very partial, but sufficient. We have DNA from Hernando Colón, his son,” Lorente said in the documentary, per Reuters. “And both in the Y chromosome (male) and in the mitochondrial DNA (transmitted by the mother) of Hernando there are traits compatible with Jewish origin.”
The wire titled its article “Columbus was a Sephardic Jew from Western Europe, study finds.” Headlines in New York Post (“Christopher Columbus was a Sephardic Jew from Western Europe, study finds”), BBC (“Columbus probably Spanish and Jewish, study says”) and Fox News (“Columbus remains, verified after 500 years, show he was Jewish: documentary”) hedged similarly, while a Guardian headline stated that Columbus “may” have been Jewish and the Telegraph that “Christopher Columbus was secretly Jewish.”
“The recent DNA evidence regarding Columbus is very interesting and helps to illuminate his biography and the era in which he lived. I would offer one caveat, though: While it indicates that Columbus had Jewish heritage, it does not indicate that Columbus was a professing, Jew,” said Jonathan Ray, professor of Jewish studies at Georgetown University.
According to Ray, who is the author of the 2023 book Jewish Life in Medieval Spain: A New History, there is no proof that Columbus (1451-1506) lived a Jewish life, “nor even as a crypto-Jew,” and the historical record indicates he was Catholic.
“Rather, it would seem to indicate that he was a converso, or New Christian as they are often called—that is, a descendant of Iberian Jews who had converted to Christianity under duress during the century leading up to Spain’s expulsion of the Jews in 1492,” Ray told JNS. “Some of these conversos remained steadfast to Judaism, albeit in secret, leaving Spain and Portugal to return to Judaism in other lands.”
Some conversos stayed in the Iberian Peninsula and “although they met stiff resistance from many of their ‘old Christian’ neighbors, fully embraced Christianity and eventually integrated into Iberian society,” Ray added. “We already know of Jewish converts, who became important bishops in late-medieval Spain. Now, it seems, we also know of a major explorer who also had Jewish roots.”
Christopher
Columbus statue (1955) by Edoardo Alfieri, which was installed at City
Hall in Columbus, Ohio, photographed in 2018. The sculpture was removed
in 2020 for political reasons.
Several experts told JNS that the public should regard the claim in the documentary skeptically.
“This is a story that never dies,” Ronnie Perelis, associate professor of Sephardic studies at the Bernard Revel Graduate School of Jewish Studies of Yeshiva University, told JNS.
“For over a century, if not since his own lifetime, people have been obsessed with Columbus’s origins. He is a fascinating, flawed and enigmatic figure,” added Perelis, the author of the 2016 book Blood and Faith: Family and Identity in the Early Modern Sephardic Atlantic.
“I encourage people to read his own writings to appreciate his complex identity—he was an autodidact, who took advantage of the explosion of knowledge after the birth of printing to create an eclectic theology that had many Judaic elements—but in a deeply Christian, mystical vein,” Perelis said. “Genetics doesn’t make someone Jewish.”
In 1992, Jonathan Sarna, professor of American Jewish history at Brandeis University, published an essay on “the mythical Jewish Columbus and the history of America’s Jews.”
“”In the interim, Columbus has been reviled in many circles and Columbus Day in cities like mine has been replaced by Indigenous Persons Day,” Sarna told JNS. “Dubious science that looks to prove ‘genetically’ that Columbus was Jewish is no more persuasive than earlier theories of this kind. All we know for sure is that Columbus had much to hide.”
Jason Guberman, executive director of the American Sephardi Federation, told JNS that “there have long been suspicions that Columbus was Jewish or had Sephardic Jewish roots.”
The year 1492 was not only when Columbus “sailed the ocean blue with the support of King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella,” according to Guberman. “That was also the year the Spanish rulers promulgated the Alhambra Decree, or Edict of Expulsion, completing a process that began in 1391 to destroy the Iberian Peninsula’s Jewish communities by conversion or deportation.”
“Sephardim were nevertheless prized for their erudition and technical skills. Columbus’s crew included several conversos, most notably his interpreter, Luis de Torres. For those who had been converted or were the descendants of converts, so-called ‘new Christians,’ there was always the risk of an accusation leading to torture, ruin and death at the hands of the Inquisition,” Guberman said.
“Now that the question of Sephardic Jewish ancestry has been settled, there should be renewed scholarly inquiry into Simon Wiesenthal’s thesis that Columbus was on a ‘secret mission’ to find a safe haven for his persecuted people,” Guberman added. “For example, how the unusual tolerance of Columbus’s family for conversos led to an open Jewish community at Jamaica.”
Who ‘owns’ Columbus?
Ori Soltes, an author and former director of the B’nai B’rith Klutznick National Jewish Museum, told JNS that “the DNA issue that focuses on the so-called tomb of Columbus in Seville is fraught with political issues pertaining to national pride and with it, which country can claim Columbus as its own.”
Soltes, who also teaches at Georgetown, said that writer and researcher Peter Dickson, of Virginia, has shown in “meticulous studies” that “spurious DNA claims aside, Columbus was a child of his era and his bloodline mixed Spanish, Genoese and French strains—indeed, more than just these three—as well as intertwining Jewish and Christian strains.” (JNS sought comment from Dickson.)
That Columbus has both Jewish and Christian blood is unsurprising “given that he set sail from a country that had spent a century producing various sorts of conversos by the time of his first voyage,” Soltes said.
“Other aspects of his story, from the way he signed his letters to his son to his insistence that his ships sail before midnight of the day (Aug. 3) when the edict of expulsion was to go into effect also point to the interweave of religious and national identities that would have comprised him,” he added.
Matt Goldish, a history professor and chair of Jewish history at Ohio State University, told JNS that an “extensive older literature” has made the claim that Columbus was Jewish.
Among the reasons that claim has been made are “why did a Genoese mariner speak and write in Spanish?” and “why did Columbus leave some money to certain Jews or conversos?” Goldish said. Columbus also had an “odd signature,” he added. (Some have claimed that the explorer wrote the Hebrew letters bet and hay in the corner of his documents.)
Monument
to Christopher Columbus in Barcelona, Spain, with depiction of the
explorer with King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella.
“All of this was interesting but by no means conclusive. DNA evidence is much stronger, but it also has its problems,” Goldish told JNS. “DNA, for example, does not actually tell you that someone is or is not Jewish—it says that most Jews from a certain region seems to have common ancestors, and a given person shares to whatever extent in the DNA of those ancestors.”
The Ohio State professor said that the DNA evidence seems “pretty strong,” but cautioned that “Jewish ancestry does not mean Columbus was a Jew.”
“What it probably means is that he was a descendant of conversos (sometimes called marranos) who had converted in Spain or elsewhere in Western Europe during the 14th or 15th centuries,” he said.
Journalists who cover Jewish topics also approached the news cautiously. “The chatter around the ‘Columbus was Jewish’ report gets at the complications of Jewishness, nationality and the use of genes as proof of ‘identity,’” wrote Jonah Goldberg, editor-in-chief of The Dispatch.
“Columbus was obviously and explicitly a Christian. But he was also— apparently—of Sephardic Jewish descent,” Goldberg wrote. If Columbus was the latter, “what? He wasn’t Spanish? Or Italian? Or Christian? Lots of Spaniards have Moorish genes, are they not Spaniards? Italians are a melting pot of genetic lineages from all over the Mediterranean,” he added.
“It wasn’t until fairly recently that Italy was considered a single nation or had a single language. The fact that Columbus was of Jewish descent doesn’t necessarily answer many of the questions the researchers were trying to answer,” Goldberg wrote. “But it does raise some more interesting questions.”
Andrew Koss, a historian and senior editor at Mosaic magazine, wrote that “I highly doubt the study ‘proves’ anything.”
“I don’t see how they can be sure they have Columbus’s DNA,” he wrote. “And DNA can’t prove someone was Jewish, only show it’s more or less likely.”
Whether Columbus had any Jewish ancestry, the explorer wrote approvingly in his journals of the Catholic monarchs, Ferdinand II of Aragon and Isabella I of Castile, expelling Jews from their kingdom.
“I saw the Moorish king come out of the gates of the city and kiss the royal hands of your highnesses,” he wrote, “and your highnesses, as Catholic Christians … took thought to send me, Christopher Columbus, to the said parts of India, to see those princes and peoples and lands.”
The king and queen also dispatched him, he wrote, to observe “the manner which should be used to bring about their conversion to our holy faith, and ordained that I should not go by land to the eastward, by which way it was the custom to go, but by way of the west, by which down to this day we do not know certainly that anyone has passed.”
“Therefore, having driven out all the Jews from your realms and lordships in the same month of January, your highnesses commanded me that, with a sufficient fleet, I should go to the said parts of India, and for this accorded me great rewards and ennobled me so that from that time henceforth I might style myself ‘don’ and be high admiral of the ocean sea and viceroy and perpetual governor of the islands and continent which I should discover,” he added, “and that my eldest son should succeed to the same position, and so on from generation to generation forever.”
‘Colonialism’
Goldish, the Ohio State professor, told JNS that at a time when “colonialism” is denounced widely, he is concerned about potential Jew-hatred surrounding the announcement about Columbus.
“The ahistorical attitude that Columbus is to blame for everything Europeans did in the Americas is itself highly problematic. If you look at his biography, you learn that he was very careful with native people and was not a slave owner, which was not so common for hidalgos,” or noblemen, Goldish said.
“He is, however, used as the fulcrum on which to place all blame for the sins of Europeans in the Americas,” Goldish told JNS. “Once Columbus is to blame for everything, the antisemitism melds with the post-colonial and postmodern trends to create a truly dangerous idea.”
He noted that post-colonialists view Zionism as a European movement “to steal Palestine from the poor native Arabs.”
“As ahistorical as this claim is, it may create a perfect storm of Jew-hatred if the same Jews caused the destruction of native American civilization and of native Palestinian civilization,” Goldish said. “We might next expect a conspiracy picture out of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, but coming from the left this time.”
No comments:
Post a Comment