The Jewish left botched its response to the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting
By Jonathan Neumann
New York Post
November 3, 2018
The aftermath of Pittsburgh has been a disgrace.
In ordinary times it would have been unseemly to comment on the atrocity at the Tree of Life Synagogue so soon after it unfolded. It was the most deadly anti-Semitic attack this country has ever seen. It should have given us pause and brought us together.
But these are not ordinary times. Donald Trump is president.
Before the bodies of the dead had gone cold, let alone been buried and mourned, the Jewish left sacrificed an opportunity to cry in unity and chose instead to call for division.
Bend the Arc, reputedly the largest Jewish social-justice organization in the nation, published a letter blaming the president for the attack. Other groups, such as The Jewish Vote and If Not Now, also saw the attack as a chance to castigate the president.
Apparently these liberal groups need reminding that the shooting at a Jewish community center in Kansas occurred during the Obama administration.
Instead of trying to score political points, would not a more appropriate response have been to urge calm upon the hyper-partisanship that has seen both sides court incivility?
Yet more egregious, however, was the excoriation by Jewish liberals of their fellow Jews who support President Trump. Another three Jewish social justice groups — Torah Trumps Hate, Hitoreri and Uri L’Tzedek — penned an open letter to the National Council of Young Israel (NCYI), blasting the Orthodox synagogue umbrella group for its statement condemning the attack.
NCYI’s sin?
Concluding its heartfelt statement by expressing appreciation for “the strong words of support from President Trump and the administration in urging everyone to work together to combat anti-Semitism.”
Meanwhile, Franklin Foer, the former editor of The New Republic, wrote: “Any strategy for enhancing the security of American Jewry should involve shunning Trump’s Jewish enablers. Their money should be refused, their presence in synagogues not welcome. They have placed their community in danger.”
This brazen attempt to blame Jewish backers of the president for the attack and excommunicate them from their community is scandalous. It is also a dog whistle for animosity toward more traditionalist Jews, who constitute one of the most pro-Trump demographics in the country (indeed several serve as high-ranking officials in the administration).
Such sentiments reveal what underlies the entire liberal Jewish response to Pittsburgh: For them, Judaism is synonymous with liberalism. Donald Trump is cast as an enemy of the Jews not because he has shown any hostility to the Jewish people or the Jewish State (quite the contrary) but because he is an enemy of liberalism. The same goes for his “Jewish enablers,” who have allegedly betrayed their community by backing him.
As it happens, Trump has done more than any other president to prevent attacks on Jews, including by cutting funds to the Palestinian Authority. This courageous decision thwarts its pay-to-slay policy of issuing financial reward to terrorist murderers of Jews. But no matter. The Jewish social-justice chorale serves at the altar of liberalism and Trump is their Antichrist (just as, lest we forget, George W. Bush was before him).
Degrading Judaism to advance their petty politics, as the Jewish social justice movement has always done, is insulting enough. Using Pittsburgh’s dead to do so is altogether grotesque.
But if these critics really want to talk about betrayal of the Jewish people, consider who supported the nuclear deal with Iran, which enriched the world’s most heinous terror state and which legitimized the pursuit of the bomb by an Islamo-fascist regime bent on annihilating over 6 million Jews.
And consider who for decades paid lip service to the justice of recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of the Jewish State and moving the American embassy but then, when it actually happened, opposed it or gave it only half-hearted support — solely because it was implemented by a president whom they detest.
Following the shooting, a number of American Jewish newspaper editors came together and authored a joint editorial sounding the alarm on rising anti-Semitism in the US, and declaring #WeAreAllJews. This is a fitting retort to those who have tried to claim that some of their co-religionists are not.
Such expressions of solidarity within the Jewish community are welcome and must be encouraged. That, and not partisanship, is what will make the memory of those who lost their lives in Pittsburgh a blessing.
EDITOR’S NOTE: Fuck the Jewish left! I’m beginning to believe their religion is liberalism, not Judaism.
11 comments:
The Jewish left is not the problem. The problem is self-hating Jews like yourself.
You are so far up Trumps ass you cant see or don't care that he is a rabid anti-Semite.
From one landsman to another, you are a modern day kapo, Howie.
By kapo, I take it you don't mean the Hawaiian god.
As for sticking one's head up an ass, which ass have you stuck your head up in ... Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama?
Let me add that if Trump, the father of a Jewish daughter and grandfather of Jewish children, is anti-Semitic, he is far less anti-Semitic than Barack Obama who was mentored by one of this country's most notorious anti-Semites, Jeremiah Wright.
Jews are being murdered in synagogues and you don't see a problem with Trump.
Sad.
If you are a rabbi, what is really sad and a shame to boot, is that you blame Trump for the murder of Jews. Some rabbi!
I blame Trump for embracing white nationalists. "There are good people on both sides" as he said, referring to Nazi's, after Charlottsville. There may be good Nazi's but I haven't met any.
He is equivical when it comes to condemning the anti-semitic dog
whistles from his supporters.
Rabbi or not, you are the typical liberal Jew looking for any reason to support Democrats and playing the anti-Semitic card against Republicans whenever possible.
Of course there are Jew-haters among Trump's supporters as there are Israel-haters among Democrats. But to stereotype Trump's supporters as anti-Semites is like any stereotyping - it's for the most part not true.
To play the anti-Semitic card against Trump who has Jewish family members and has been the most Israel-friendly president since Harry Truman is downright shameful.
It's Jewish Trump-haters like you and the above Anon who called me a kapo that fuel anti-Semitism in this country. You are so blind in your support of Democrats that you can't see that.
Someone that is not willing to stand up to white supremacists because it may cost him votes is a spineless anti-Semite. The fact that he moved an embassy or has Jewish relatives does not change the fact that 11 innocent Jews were slaughtered for the "crime' of being Jewish and attending a synagogue. Trump's vitriol was adopted by the shooter."We are being invaded"
If Trump is not an anti-Semite, why would he not have simply condemned the Charlottsville Nazi's as opposed to mentioning the "Good people" on the Nazi side?
I have yet to meet a good Nazi, and I don't think you have either.
I guess you are of the opinion that we should just tolerate a little antisemitism, and as long as the death toll is under a dozen , you are OK with it, because after all , he moved the embassy and has a son in law that is orthodox?
What so you call someone who thinks there are good people on the Nazi's side? An anti-semite
What do you call someone who is Jewish, a sycophant and makes excuses for the anti-swmite?
A kapo
Rabbi, under your logic, Bernie Sanders should be responsible for the shooting of Steve Scalise at the congressional softball game.
Trump has been a great friend to Israel. What other sovereign country does not get to choose its own capital? Bush and Obama both promised to move the embassy, but reneged.
Both Trump's daughter and son in law are Jewish.
The only person responsible for the shooting at the Philadelphia synagogue is the shooter himself, not Trump or anyone else.
Rabbi Dave, check out today's (Friday) BarkGrowlBite. I responded to your disgusting comments with a new post.
Post a Comment